Put too much in your TFSA? It happens more often than you might think, usually because of a re-deposit in the same year or accounts at more than one institution. The good news is that it is fixable, and the cost stays small if you act quickly. Here is how the penalty works and the steps to fix it.
How the penalty works
The CRA charges a tax of 1% per month on the highest excess amount in your TFSA in each month, for as long as the excess stays in. For example, a $2,000 excess left in for three months costs about $60. The tax keeps adding up every month until you withdraw the excess or new room opens up on January 1.
Use our TFSA room calculator to check your numbers; it estimates the penalty if you are over.
How people usually end up over the limit
- Re-depositing a withdrawal in the same year. Money you take out only becomes room again on January 1 of the next year.
- Accounts at more than one place. The limit is per person, not per account, so two TFSAs share one limit.
- Moving a TFSA the wrong way. Withdrawing cash and depositing it at a new institution counts as a new contribution. A direct transfer between institutions does not.
- Relying on an out-of-date CRA figure. The room shown in CRA My Account may not include this year’s transactions yet.
How to fix it, step by step
- Confirm the amount. Add up every contribution and withdrawal across all your TFSAs using your account statements, and compare with your room.
- Withdraw the excess right away. This stops the 1% from growing. If you hope to have the tax waived, the CRA generally expects you to withdraw the excess along with any income it earned.
- File a TFSA Return (Form RC243) if you owe the tax. It is due by June 30 of the year after the over-contribution, and any tax owing is due by then too.
- Ask for a waiver if it was an honest mistake. The CRA can waive or cancel all or part of the tax if it finds it fair, for example when the excess was a reasonable error and you removed it without delay. You request this with a letter explaining what happened and why a waiver is fair, sent through “Submit documents” in your CRA account or by mail.
If the CRA has already written to you about an excess amount, follow the instructions in that letter.
How to avoid it next time
- Keep your own running total of contributions and withdrawals, not just the CRA figure.
- Do not re-deposit money withdrawn this year unless you have unused room.
- When switching providers, ask the new institution for a direct transfer.
FAQ
Does investment growth count toward the limit?
No. Growth inside a TFSA does not use room, so a balance above your contributions is not an over-contribution.
Will withdrawing the excess fix it immediately?
It stops the 1% tax from building from that month on. You may still owe tax for the months the excess was in, unless the CRA waives it.
Is there any free over-contribution buffer like the RRSP’s $2,000?
No. The TFSA has no buffer; any amount over your room is an excess.
Source: Canada Revenue Agency, If you have to pay tax on a TFSA. Rules checked November 2026.
Get new Canadian money tools by email
A short email when we add a calculator or update the yearly limits (like the new TFSA limit each January). No spam, never more than a couple of emails a month.